Posted by Tha_Dude at 202.167.41.215 on July 01, 2000 at 23:07:29:
In Reply to: Holden is Jacks liver... posted by LegomanQ on July 01, 2000 at 22:47:38:
Does kev actually say they are or is it an assumption youve made. If kev said this it makes little sense as Banky existed well before Allysa was even introduced. And fight club had a reason for an alternate personality. Hell you could look into every kev smith flick and come up with the same accusations. Fight club was a fuckin great film so dont knock it.
Tha Dude
: I just finished my Chasing Amy DVD and just realised that Fincher ripped off Kevin Smith to do Fight Club. You see, Holden & Banky are in fact the same person. Holden created Banky as a way to deal with his "gay as all fuck" personality. This is why you don't see Alyssa talk much to Banky throughout the entire film....
: Cheers
: The Legoman