Posted by The Doug at neko2.syix.com on April 10, 2002 at 22:33:48:
In Reply to: Re: goofy-foot posted by Malcolm Load on April 10, 2002 at 20:09:08:
: : : Heavens Gate was far superior to The DEER HUNTER
: : wrong. i liked heavens gate a great deal but to me the deer hunter speaks on so many levels and hits closer to home.
:
: ----Oh......Had a friend crippled in 'nam lately
: Played Russian Roulette with pals?
no and no. what i meant by closer to home was the whole anti-war statement made by the movie. and how friends and family are torn apart by war. i think we have all been touched by war in some way.
:
: : : Secondly...Ciminos best film was his first....THUNDERBOLT AND LIGHTFOOT
: : another great movie but not his best. i cant believe you are dismissing the deer hunter like this. the russian rolette scene alone blows heavens gate and thunderbolt and lightfoot away.
:
: ----The Russian roulette scene is easy drama......
easy drama or not, that scene IS deniro's finest work. there is such a ferocity in his face that it burns the film. watch the scene again and see how deniro looks like he really wants to kill that actor that is slapping him.
: And the rabbits in the trunk scene in THUNDERBOLT blows THE DEER CHEESE outta the water.
: Oy vay!
: that fucking ENDLESS wedding scene
i defend the OVERLONG wedding scene. it makes the ending so much more heartbreaking. he see during the wedding the way these friends interact with each other and are so much a part of each others life. then the war tears their world apart. nothing will be the way is was...ever again.
-erik