Posted by jthecamb at wv-morgantown-cdnt1-bg1-4g-110.mgtnwv.adelphia.net on March 21, 2003 at 02:33:02:
In Reply to: Re: Color me Amish.... posted by ItsJustCrissy on March 21, 2003 at 02:29:53:
And the edge goes to. . .
Music - Moulin Rouge
Performances - Moulin Rouge... Ewan Magregor and Nicole Kidman kicked ass. The only strength of Chicago was that there were more characters, thus more variety in music... but in my opinion it just made Ewan and Nic more impressive that they practically carried it themselves.
Story - Moulin Rouge... Chicago is mainly just music. The story of Moulin Rouge is what kept me hooked. I wouldn't have liked Chicago had I not seen Moulin Rouge first.
Overall look - Moulin Rouge.. This may be the closest aspect Chicago comes to Red Mill, but I just think that Moulin Rouge looks amazing. A true masterpiece of special effects, costumes, everything....