Posted by Ryall at sm12349.rpa.com on March 08, 2004 at 19:31:12:
In Reply to: POLL for a summer like California day... posted by tommybruce on March 08, 2004 at 18:56:08:
: Which is the better movie?
: Spielberg
: RAIDERS or SCHINDLER
Technically and emotionally? Schindler. Viscerally, and enjoyment-wise, Raiders.
: Scorsese
: GOODFELLAS or TAXI DRIVER
Goodfellas doesn't resonate as much but it was much more well-made, well-acted, well-told and captivating to watch. Taxi Driver was dull for long stretches.
: Zemeckis
: BACK TO THE FUTURE or FORREST GUMP
Gump plays with your emotions more and shows more technical prowess, but Back to the Future is so much more fun.
: Tarantino
: PULP FICTION or KILL BILL
Hmm...without seeing the second half of Bill, it's hard to say overall, but I loved Pulp Fiction like nothing I'd seen before it. Although I felt like that with Kill Bill to a degree, too, but Pulp is better all around. Although I prefer Bill-era Uma.
: Pixar
: MONSTER'S INC or FINDING NEMO
Nemo.
: Columbus
: HOME ALONE or HARRY POTTER (any of them)
Ugh...I suppose the second Potter. Well, both Potters look great, but they left me a little cold somehow. And the second Home Alone was just sadistic. Can I possibly be picking the first Home Alone here? I think I am. Although "None of the above" seems to be the best response.
: Kubrick
: FULL METAL JACKET or THE SHINING
I love love love the first half of Jacket, but something about the cold tone of The Shining works for me top to bottom. That and the old woman nudity.
: Anderson
: BOOGIE NIGHTS or MAGNOLIA
Boogie Nights, I guess, but both were way too long.
: Dante
: GREMLINS or GREMLINS 2
Phoebe's much cuter in the first one, and the overall first movie's cuter all around, but the second one is a little...ahh, hell, the first one.
: Jeunet
: AMELIE or THE CITY OF LOST CHILDREN
City is more impressive but Amelie's the only one I've watched more than once. Nice, including him.
: Smith
: CLERKS or DOGMA
Dogma's still probably the best-written, as in deepest, movie Kevin's made but you always remember your first time more findly, you know?
: That's all for now. Have fun kids. And no fighting.
I hope I have fun kids someday.